Ex-leader Donald Trump asserted on Sunday that Ukraine had demonstrated no gratitude for US attempts to halt the conflict, as American, Ukrainian, and international delegates gathered in Geneva to discuss a plan for peace that calls for significant concessions from Ukraine to Moscow.
Questions Over Proposal’s Authorship
Polish leader Tusk questioned where Trump’s proposal originated, following an apparent admission by American diplomat Rubio that the text was originally drafted by Moscow.
In a social media post, the Polish president noted that EU officials, together with Canada and Japan, were ready to work on the 28-point proposal. The proposal envisages Kyiv ceding territory to Russia and making further compromises, including limiting the military forces and not joining Nato.
He remarked that there were “some reservations” before proceeding further. Pointedly, he commented, “We need to determine with certainty who is the author and where was it created.”
Speculation on Plan’s Drafting
The document was allegedly prepared by Kirill Dmitriev, Vladimir Putin’s envoy, alongside a US envoy, Steve Witkoff. Analysis due to the use of language in the document indicates it may have been composed in Russia’s language and subsequently rendered into English.
A group of US senators claimed that the Secretary of State informed them the plan was not US-authored. They said, it was a Moscow’s proposal deliberately leaked by Russia, which the US then forwarded to Kyiv. He later insisted that the America did draft the plan, with “input” from both Russia and Ukraine.
Contradictory Statements and Backlash
Amid contradictory statements and a backlash from GOP lawmakers, the president stepped back from his earlier demand that Ukrainian President Zelenskyy agree on the agreement by the deadline. In remarks, Trump stated it was “not my final offer”, paving the way for major revisions.
In an online post on Sunday, Trump avoided blaming Russia for the war. Instead, he claimed his predecessor, Joe Biden, was at fault and had given “everything” to Ukraine for without cost. He wrote, “UKRAINE ‘LEADERSHIP’ HAS SHOWN NO THANKS FOR OUR EFFORTS, AND EUROPE CONTINUES TO BUY OIL FROM RUSSIA.”
European Leaders Criticize Russian Terms
European leaders have made clear that the terms set by Russia backed by Trump are mostly unacceptable. The European Commission president, Ursula von der Leyen, emphasized that Ukraine’s borders could not be altered through aggression. A limit on the military size would render it “vulnerable to future attack”, she noted.
The German leader, Friedrich Merz, said he was doubtful an deal could be concluded soon, given the “current differences”. One western ambassador remarked that the Europeans would publicly praise US mediation in the near future, while quietly seeking to revise the proposal and improve its terms.
Ongoing Talks in Switzerland
On the weekend, US envoys arrived in Geneva together with the American military official, Dan Driscoll, who held talks recently with Zelenskyy in Kyiv.
They met a team from Kyiv led by Zelenskyy’s chief of staff, Yermak. Prior to that, the Kyiv team spoke with European diplomats, including Keir Starmer’s national security adviser, Jonathan Powell.
Pushback from European Officials
In a unified response, EU delegates have said that the draft as it stands curtails the nation’s independence by ruling out Nato membership and imposing terms for its European Union entry. If approved, it would establish a risky norm, they assert. It also prevents a international troops for the country and limits where Nato aircraft could be stationed.
One diplomat noted that Putin was attempting to revert 30 years on Europe’s security architecture and to enforce demands made shortly before his full-scale war. Putin called for Nato’s military forces to withdraw to their 1997 borders, before the Eastern European nations joined the Nato pact.
Ukraine’s Difficult Position
Zelenskyy has stated that his nation faces an impossible choice between compromising sovereignty and losing a major ally. He has sought to engage positively with a unpredictable US administration seemingly determined to resolve the war on Moscow’s harsh conditions.
“We need to halt the violence, and we must ensure that the conflict does not resume,” he wrote. A American representative commented, “We hope to iron out the final details … to draft a deal that is advantageous to them. Nothing will be agreed on until the two presidents meet,” the official said, meaning the US and Ukrainian heads of state.