In a significant legal challenge, warehouse club leader Costco has filed a lawsuit targeting the White House, contending that its use of emergency powers to levy extensive duties oversteps legal boundaries. The retailer is demanding reimbursement for tariffs paid and petitioning the judiciary to halt the collections.
Legal Grounds: Exceeding Statutory Authority
The lawsuit, lodged with the Court of International Trade, focuses on the administration's use of the IEEPA emergency law. Costco claims this legislation was misapplied to impose the duties. Citing the statute's text, the retailer noted that IEEPA confers authority solely for addressing an "unusual and extraordinary threat" and significantly "omits the word ‘tariff’ or any term of equivalent meaning".
"The vehicle is the imposition of taxes on Americans, and that has traditionally remained a fundamental authority of Congress," remarked Chief Justice John Roberts during recent oral arguments.
The Urgency Factor
While the Supreme Court is poised to rule on the legality of the duties in the coming months, Costco's lawsuit argues immediate action is necessary. The reason stems from government rules referred to as "liquidation," where the customs agency finalizes tariff amounts roughly ten months following goods are imported. Once liquidation occurs, legal precedent suggests importers may lose the ability to recover refunds, "even if the original lawfulness of a tariff is subsequently ruled to be unlawful".
Therefore, even if the Supreme Court invalidates the tariffs, Costco fears it could be unable to recover money previously submitted if too much time has elapsed.
The Retailer's Demands
In its filing, Costco is asking the trade court to:
- Declare the contested duties unlawful.
- Halt the continued collection of these duties.
- Order a refund for any duties the retailer has already paid.
- Block finalization of its customs bills to preserve its right to a future repayment.
Broader Context
The scale of customs income has surged. Reports indicate total collections in the 2025 budget year soared to $195 billion, a significant rise from $118 billion the previous year. Monthly collections are said to have increased from around $7 billion to $30 billion during that period.
While Costco has not revealed its specific tariff bill, it has stated that roughly one-third of its American revenue comes from imported goods, with almost 50% originating from key trading partners.
This lawsuit places a spotlight on the ongoing tension between executive authority and congressional prerogatives over international commerce, with vast sums of money possibly dangling in the balance.